In today’s rapidly evolving job market, companies are shifting from hiring solely based on skillsets to considering candidates’ overall attitude, aptitude, and behavior. To explore this topic more, we invited Tim Meurer, an HR leader with 18 years of experience building successful teams through personality assessments, leadership, and coaching. Tim provided invaluable insights on whether personality assessments should be part of hiring processes and the potential biases that could accompany their use.
Are podcasts more of your thing? You can also listen to this event on our LinkedIn here!
Why Personality Assessments Matter
Tim emphasized that the future of hiring is not just about what candidates know but how they fit into the company culture and behave in the workplace. He explained that companies increasingly prioritize behavioral and cultural fit over specific experience. This trend is particularly beneficial for university students and early-career professionals, as it opens doors to opportunities that might have been closed if the focus were solely on previous experience. Behavioral assessments play a crucial role in this new hiring paradigm, allowing companies to train new hires on the job while ensuring they align with the company’s values and culture.
The Right Way to Use Personality Assessments
Personality assessments should never be used as the sole differentiator in hiring decisions. Instead, they should be viewed as just another data point, similar to a resume. “These assessments are a tool to help ask more relevant questions during interviews and understand why candidates might behave in certain ways once they become employees,” Tim explained.
One of the most significant risks associated with personality assessments is the potential for bias. Tim warned that hiring managers might automatically decline candidates who don’t think or act like they do simply because of the unknown. This is a dangerous trap, as it can lead to homogenous teams that lack the diverse thinking necessary for innovation and success. To combat this, Tim recommends developing a team profile using tools like the Predictive Index, which can highlight gaps in your current team. When hiring, it’s essential to look for candidates who have the required skills and bring the behaviors needed to round out your team.
Avoiding Bias and Embracing Diverse Thinkers
Tim stressed that using personality assessments as a differentiator introduces bias into the hiring process. “Without diverse thinkers, you will never have a fully functioning team,” he stated. Hiring managers must be vigilant in ensuring that personality assessments do not exclude candidates who could bring valuable new perspectives to the table.
Once candidates understand their behaviors, their careers can take off—authentically. Tim shared stories of individuals who, after gaining insights into their behavior through assessments, were able to thrive in their roles and advance in their careers.
The Candidate Experience Matters
Tim also highlighted the importance of treating candidates with respect and care throughout recruitment. He noted that recruitment often treats candidates like a hiring transaction, which can be damaging. Whether or not you hire a candidate, they should leave the experience with something valuable. Personality assessments can be a tool to achieve this, offering candidates feedback on why they might not fit a particular role and helping them understand their behavior for future interviews.
Tim Meurer’s insights underscore the importance of using personality assessments thoughtfully and strategically. While these tools can be incredibly valuable in understanding candidates’ behaviors and ensuring a good cultural fit, they should complement—not replace—other aspects of the hiring process. By doing so, companies can build diverse, high-functioning teams that drive success and innovation.
Want to learn more from expert HR leaders about the upcoming trends? Follow us on LinkedIn to catch our upcoming Live.